Reporting A Claim

Claims Reporting Procedure

We are available to handle your claim reports by phone or you may also report it directly to your insurance company. If you choose to call the carrier directly to file a claim, below are the phone numbers for each company represented.

Carrier Claims Department Phone Numbers

A-Central
1-866-222-2242

American Modern Home
1-866-267-7678 • Fax: 1-513-947-4000

Central Cooperative Insurance Company
1-800-621-9875

Classic Collectors Ins. Prog
1-800-348-4269 • Fax: 1-869-298-2527

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company
1-800-724-9876 • Fax: 1-607-844-3526
e-mail: claims@drydenmutual.com

Erie Insurance Group
1-888-822-3743 • Glass Claim: 1-800-552-3743

Erie (Rochester)
1-800-333-0823 x 6500

Erie & Niagara Insurance Company
1-800-234-9876 • Fax: 1-716-632-9621

Foremost
1-800-527-3907

GMAC
1-800-468-3466 • Fax: 1-336-726-2300
Status: 1-888-233-4575

General Casualty
1-860-408-3268

Hagerty
1-800-747-5348

Harleysville Insurance Company
1-800-892-8877 • Fax: 1-800-441-4118

Infinity
1-800-782-1020

Kemper National Insurance Group
1-888-252-2799 • Fax: 1-877-329-5367

Lo Vullo Asso
1-800-876-3065 • Fax: 1-716-856-8057

Merchant Insurance Group
1-800-952-5246 • Safelite Glass: 1-877-446-0431
Fax: 1-800-235-6304

MidState Mutual Insurance
Fax Accord: 252-4312

National Grange Mutual Insurance Company
1-877-425-2467 • Fax: 1-877-282-3844
Glass Claim: 1-800-887-5944

New York Central Mutual Insurance
1-800-355-1717 • Fax: 1-607-965-2136
Towing/Glass: 1-888-234-6926
Flood: 1-800-787-6677 • Fax: 1-301-279-0364

Progressive
1-800-274-4499
Local: 785-8124 OR 788-3983

Security Mutual Insurance Company
1-800-822-1232
Fax: 1-607-257-5230 OR 1-607-266-0635

Travelers Insurance Group
1-800-252-4633
Commercial & WC: 1-800-832-7839